Field Guide No. 02 · The Greek Islands
There are somewhere around two hundred inhabited Greek islands. The trip is decided by which two you pick and how much time you refuse to spend moving between them.
The classic mistake is not choosing the wrong island. It is choosing four of them. People arrive with ten days and a list, and they spend three of those days in ports, on boats, and in the specific misery of packing a suitcase at six in the morning. What they wanted was slow mornings. What they booked was a relay.
This guide is organized around that constraint. Which islands reward a long stay, which are better as a short second leg, how the ferry network actually behaves, and when a house with a kitchen and a shaded terrace beats the best hotel on the island. Rates and crossing times move with the season. Treat every number here as illustrative.
The argument
Every island change costs most of a day. Nobody prices that in until they are living it.
Count it honestly. Checkout is at eleven and the ferry is at two, so the morning is gone. The port wants you there early, the crossing is two to five hours, and the arrival port is rarely near the hotel. By the time you have checked in and found dinner it is eight in the evening and you have seen a harbour, a deck, and a taxi. Do that twice in ten days and you have spent a fifth of the holiday in transit for the privilege of saying you saw three islands.
Four nights per island is the number that works. Three is the floor, and it only works when the connection is short and direct. My standing shape is two islands in ten days and three in fourteen, and I will argue hard for one island and a rented boat before I will build a four-island itinerary for anyone who used the words “relaxing” in our first call.
The second thing worth understanding early: these islands are not variations on one theme. The Cyclades are the white-and-blue ones, dry and volcanic and windy. The Ionian, on the other side of the country, is green, olive-covered and Venetian, and looks more like the Adriatic than the Aegean. Crete is large enough to have its own mountains, its own cuisine and a four-hour drive from end to end. Choosing between them is a choosing-a-country decision, not a choosing-a-beach one.
Santorini
Both things are true at once. Santorini is genuinely one of the great sights in the Mediterranean, a drowned volcano with a village balanced on its rim, and it is genuinely overrun for eight hours a day in season. Those facts coexist, and the trip depends entirely on which side of them you organize around.
The crowding is concentrated rather than general. Cruise ships tender passengers ashore mid-morning and reclaim them in the early evening, and almost all of that traffic lands in two places: Oia and Fira. The caldera path at seven in the morning is nearly empty. Ammoudi at nine is a fishing harbour. The crush at the Oia castle for sunset, which is the image everyone has of Santorini being ruined, is avoidable by the simple method of not going there and watching the same sunset from your own terrace with a drink.
My usual shape is three or four nights, not seven. Santorini is a spectacular opening or closing act and a slightly thin week. Pair it with a slower island and you get both halves of Greece.
Paros, Naxos, Milos, Sifnos, Folegandros
This is where the promise on the cover of this guide gets kept. These are Cycladic islands with the same light and the same whitewash as Santorini, without the vertical geography or the day-tripper economy, and they are where I put people who told me what they wanted was to stop.
Paros is the best-balanced of them. Naoussa is a working harbour that turned into a very good dinner town without losing the boats, the ferry connections are among the strongest in the Cyclades, and the hotel stock has improved sharply in the last decade. Antiparos sits ten minutes across the channel and is quieter again. If someone gives me one island and no other constraints, this is often the answer.
Naxos is the largest of the Cyclades and the one with a real economy underneath the tourism: cheese, potatoes, citrus, marble, and a mountain interior with villages that have nothing to do with the coast. It has the best long sandy beaches in the group, which makes it the strongest family choice in the Cyclades, and the Portara at sunset is the equal of anything on Santorini without the queue.
Milos is the volcanic one, and the least conventionally pretty until you see it from the water. Sarakiniko is a white lunar shelf running into the sea, the coastline is a chain of coves reachable mainly by boat, and a chartered day around the island is the entire reason to come. The luxury bed count is still low, which is both the appeal and the constraint.
Sifnos is a food island, with a genuine culinary tradition and pottery to match. Folegandros is small, dramatic and quiet, a cliff-top chora and very little else, and it is the one I suggest when someone says they want nothing to do.
Crete
Crete is two hundred and sixty kilometres end to end, with mountains that hold snow into spring, a gorge you walk down for six hours, four thousand years of layered history, and a food culture that Greeks themselves treat as the best in the country. Treating it as one stop on a three-island hop is the most common way to waste it.
The west is the one most people fall for. Chania has a Venetian harbour and a lanes-and-courtyards old town that is genuinely lovely to stay inside, and it puts you within reach of Balos and Elafonisi, the two lagoon beaches that do most of the island’s marketing. The catch is that both are a long drive plus a walk or a boat, and both are crowded by eleven.
The east, around Elounda and Agios Nikolaos, is where the serious resort bench sits: large properties with private beaches, spas and villa compounds, of a scale that does not exist anywhere in the Cyclades. This is the part of Greece to look at when the brief is a five-star resort with everything on site, or a multi-generational group that needs its own pool and does not want to move.
In the middle is Heraklion and Knossos, which is worth half a day with a good guide and considerably less without one, because the site is a reconstruction and it needs someone to explain what is Minoan and what is early twentieth-century concrete.
Corfu, Paxos and the Ionian
On the other side of the country, facing Italy rather than Turkey, the Ionian islands look almost nothing like the Aegean. Olive groves and cypress instead of bare rock, Venetian and British architecture instead of whitewashed cubes, and a good deal more rain, which is why everything is green.
Corfu carries a reputation problem from decades of package tourism on its southern coast, and that reputation is out of date for the parts worth knowing. The northeast coast, the stretch of small bays and olive hills between Kouloura and Agni, has quietly been a villa belt for British families for two generations, and it holds the best private-house stock in Greece. Corfu Town itself is a proper Venetian city with arcades and a cricket ground, and it is more interesting than any town in the Cyclades.
Paxos, an hour south by boat, is small, green and almost entirely low-key, with three harbour villages and a west coast of sea caves and cliffs. Antipaxos next door has two beaches with water that genuinely does look Caribbean in photographs and in person.
This is also where the promise of a villa with a library gets literal. The Ionian house stock runs to old family properties with shaded terraces, walled gardens, a cook who comes in the morning, and shelves of paperbacks left by thirty years of previous summers. That is a specific kind of holiday and there is nothing else quite like it in the country.
The chapter that saves the trip
More Greek itineraries break here than anywhere else, and almost always for the same handful of reasons. None of them are obscure. They are just invisible until you are standing in a port at seven in the morning being told the boat is not sailing.
Conventional car ferries are large, slow, stable and comparatively cheap, they carry vehicles, and they sail in most conditions. High-speed catamarans are roughly twice as fast, considerably more expensive, much less pleasant in a swell, and they are the first thing cancelled when the wind gets up. If a crossing is critical to the itinerary, I book the conventional ferry even when the fast boat is tempting, and I would rather give up ninety minutes than a day.
The meltemi is a dry north wind that blows down the Aegean mainly in July and August, sometimes for days at a stretch. It is the reason the Cyclades are not humid, and it is also the reason high-speed services get cancelled in the middle of peak season. Any August itinerary with a tight island-to-island connection needs a fallback built into it before it is booked, not improvised at the port.
This is the rule I am most insistent about in all of Greek travel. Build a night in Athens at the end of the trip. It converts the single highest-risk moment of the itinerary into a non-event, and Athens is worth an evening and a morning anyway: dinner in a roof garden with the Acropolis lit, and the Acropolis Museum before the flight.
Islands that look adjacent on a map are not necessarily connected to each other, and some pairs require backtracking toward Athens to get between them. Frequency also collapses at the shoulders of the season, so a route that runs daily in August may run twice a week in May. The connection has to be confirmed for your actual dates before the hotels are booked, not after.
Athens has more than one ferry port. Piraeus is the largest and serves most routes; Rafina is closer to the airport and serves part of the Cyclades; Lavrio serves others. Being sent to the wrong one costs an hour or more in traffic. Domestic flights also cover the bigger islands and are frequently the right answer for a long hop, particularly Santorini, Mykonos, Crete, Rhodes and Corfu.
Late May into June, and September into early October. Those windows give warm water, workable heat, sailing ferries and rates well below peak. July and August bring the meltemi, the highest prices of the year and the heaviest crowds, and are worth it mainly when school calendars leave no choice. Orthodox Easter is a genuinely beautiful and very local time to be in Greece, and it moves each year. From November to April a large share of island properties simply close, so any shoulder trip needs its hotels confirmed open before anything else is committed.
The other half of the job
Covered above and worth repeating, because it is the request I receive most and decline most. If the list has four islands on it in ten days, the honest move is to cut two and spend the saved days on a boat.
Mykonos is a genuinely beautiful island with the best beach-club infrastructure in Greece and a real nightlife economy, and in August it prices and behaves accordingly. It is an excellent choice for a group that wants exactly that. It is the wrong choice for the words “slow” and “quiet,” and I would rather send those clients to Paros or Folegandros than watch them pay peak rates for the opposite of what they asked for.
It does not save a night. It spends a day. The six-in-the-morning crossing means waking at four thirty, and the day it lands you in is a write-off in both directions.
Rented ATVs are ubiquitous in the Cyclades and are involved in a meaningful share of the serious injuries that happen to visitors every summer, on unfamiliar roads with gravel and no helmets. Take the car, or take the taxi.
Questions I get
The next step
Tell me who is coming and roughly when, and I will tell you which two islands, which way round, and why not the other four. The crossings, the house or the hotel, and the night in Athens that protects the flight home are mine to work out. Planning is complimentary.
← All field guides
